Gene-editing has started in humans: do we need to watch out!

• Victoria Gray, 34, from Mississippi has sickle cell disease.
• A genetic defect deforms the red blood cells, causing terrible bouts of pain.
• A new gene-editing treatment involves a grueling round of chemotherapy, weeks in the hospital, months of tests.
• But there’s hope…

THERE WAS AN UPROAR OVER GENE-EDITING EXPERIMENTS carried out in November 2018 by Chinese biophysicist He Jiankui. He claimed to have done experiments on human embryos that resulted in twin girls whose DNA had been engineered to make them less susceptible to contracting HIV. The controversial experiments drew condemnation in China and internationally and led to the scientist’s firing from his University in January.

The problem: it’s possible that the twins inadvertently increased their susceptibility to other infectious diseases. But there’s also a danger that the experiments made unintended modifications in their genomes, as often happens in gene-editing experiments in the laboratory, leaving the twins vulnerable to genetic diseases.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is Chines-scientist.jpg

Chinese scientist He Jiankui. Credit: Mark Schiefelbein.

CRISPR IS THE NAME OF THE MOST POPULAR GENE-EDITING TECHNIQUE. It is a method by which the genomes of living organisms may be edited (altered). Genome editing is a type of genetic engineering in which DNA is inserted, deleted, modified or replaced in the genome of a living organism. The genome of an organism is the whole of its hereditary information encoded in its DNA. The term was coined in 1920.

In 2012, Doudna and Emmanuelle Charpentier were the first to propose that CRISPR/Cas9 (enzymes from bacteria that control microbial immunity) could be used for programmable editing of genomes, which is now considered one of the most significant discoveries in the history of biology.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is Victoria-Gray-620x330.jpg

Victoria Gray.

VICTORIA GRAY, 34, OF FOREST, MISSISSIPPI, HAS SICKLE CELL DISEASE. She is the first patient ever to be publicly identified as being involved in a study testing the use of CRISPR for a genetic disease.
The following is an adaptation of the first interview, by NPR (National Public Radio) on 29 July 2019, with someone who has volunteered for one of the most highly anticipated medical experiments in decades. It’s the first attempt to use the gene-editing technique CRISPR to treat a genetic disorder in the United States.

ROB STEIN of NPR: I went to the Sarah Cannon Research Institute in Nashville to meet Victoria Gray. Victoria is just turning 34. She lives in Forest, Mississippi, with her husband and four children. Victoria’s been struggling with sickle cell disease all her life.
VICTORIA GRAY: It’s horrible. When you can’t walk or, you know, lift up a spoon and feed yourself, it gets real hard.
ROB STEIN: Sickle cell affects millions of people around the world, including about 100,000 in the United States. Most, like Victoria, are African American. A genetic defect deforms the red blood cells, making them sickle-shaped, hard and sticky, and they don’t carry oxygen like they’re supposed to, causing terrible bouts of pain.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is SickleCell-Fig1.gif
VICTORIA GRAY: Sometimes it feels like lightning strikes in my chest, and real sharp pains all over. And it’s the deep pain. You know? I can’t touch it and make it better or do anything to make it better. Sometimes I will be just balled up and crying, not able to do anything for myself.
ROB STEIN: The sickle cells have already damaged Victoria’s heart, made her weak, prone to infections, strokes and more. Many people with sickle cell can’t work or finish school. Many don’t make it past their forties.
ROB STEIN: But then Victoria heard about something new. Scientists were planning to use the gene-editing technique called CRISPR to try to treat sickle cell for the first time. She jumped at the chance to volunteer. Dr. Haydar Frangoul is running the study at the Nashville hospital.
ROB STEIN: CRISPR lets scientists make very precise changes in DNA. Doctors have started using CRISPR to try to treat cancer, mostly in China. Frangoul’s sickle cell study is part of a new wave of studies trying to use CRISPR to treat other diseases around the world.
ROB STEIN: So Dr Frangoul will be using cells that scientists have edited using CRISPR to flip a hemoglobin switch to turn the production of healthy hemoglobin back on.
DR FRANGOUL: And this opens the door for many patients to potentially be treated and have their disease modified to become a milder case or remove the long-term horrible, horrible side effects of sickle cell disease. However, this is a brand-new technology. It seems to work really well in animals. It’s completely unknown how it works in actual human beings. So there’s a lot of unknowns. It might make you sicker.
ROB STEIN: Dr. Frangoul acknowledges there are risks with experimental treatments. But he says the research will go very slowly and carefully with a lot of oversight by the Food and Drug Administration and others.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is DR-FRangoul-NL_TopDocs_018.jpg

Dr Haydar Frangoul of Nashville.

ROB STEIN: For her part, Victoria says she understands that there may be risks. The treatment’s not easy. It involves a grueling round of chemotherapy, weeks in the hospital, months of tests. And the study’s just the first step that may only benefit other patients years from now. But she can’t help but hope.
ROB STEIN: It’ll probably be months before the first clues emerge about whether CRISPR-edited cells are safe and might be working to remove sickle cell disease. And it may be years before anyone really knows how well the gene-editing might help patients like Victoria Gray.
VICTORIA GRAY: This gives me hope, if it gives me nothing else.
A potentially successful example of the application of genome editing techniques in crop improvement can be found in bananas, where scientists used CRISPR editing to inactivate the endogenous banana streak and overcome a major challenge in banana breeding.

I also happened to read the next statement, which astonished me. Can any of my readers confirm that such things are true?
By genetically modifying organisms, we can now create glow-in-the-dark cats and fish, mice with singing voices, less flatulent cows, and carbon-capturing plants.

Last point: There do appear dangers of gene-editing in humans. There is a risk that certain social, economic, and political forces will come to bear on those deemed “unfit” in an effort to pressure them to change their genetics so that they might better conform to certain external expectations.

The ethics debate has spilled onto the pages of newspapers and magazines, often with headlines heralding the arrival of “designer babies.”
PS: I write blogs about a curious mix of three topics: Science and Energy, and Inspiration and Hope, and Health and Hiking. Something for everyone!
If you would like to be able to access this information in the future, enter your email address where it says SUBSCRIBE TO BLOG at top right (its free and your email is totally protected). And if you decide later not to receive these blogs, you can unsubscribe with one easy click.

The Gray Nomad ….. Read to see the future
One time many tax collectors and outcasts came to listen to Jesus. The religious leaders started grumbling, “This man welcomes outcasts and even eats with them!” So Jesus told them a parable…
[Book of Luke, chapter 15].


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Karen Larre
Karen Larre
1 year ago

Very interesting! Thanks for sharing.

1 year ago

Ian, it seems like these procedures can be useful in future human health management, It would be wonderful if the study resulted in a positive outcome for Sickle Cell patients. This may open the doors for treating many other diseases. Thanks for your efforts in bringing this blog to your readers.

1 year ago

What a challenging topic. I hope that humanity can choose the right course in managing evolving technologies for the benefit of the human race. The promise of these technologies are potentially vast with medical breakthroughs probably possible. History tells us that there are those among us who would try to misuse these technologies for the benefit of a company or country. Can you imagine what the world would be like today if these capabilities were only in the hands of Germany or Japan in the 1930’s and 1940’s?

Nevertheless, we should not let fear limit progress – optimism and reason should prevail to promote progress.


Get the latest posts delivered to your mailbox:

Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
%d bloggers like this: